I have a great preneed team full of people who genuinely care about serving families and want to build relationships in our community. But our results are inconsistent. I've invested in training, but it doesn't seem to stick. How can I help my team succeed? -Untapped and Unsure
Dear Untapped: The great news is that you’ve already solved the hardest problem: hiring people who care.
Your team already has the passion, but what they’re missing is mastery, the difference between knowing what to do and knowing it well enough to do it in 100 different living rooms.
A Public Personnel Management study found training alone increased productivity by 22 percent. But when that training was followed by consistent one-on-one coaching, productivity climbed 88 percent.
Training is an event: a half-day session before people go back to their work. Coaching is a rhythm: a regular conversation where someone who's traveled the road before walks by their side. And that consistency is what makes knowledge stick.
Which raises the question you’re really asking: who walks with your team?
No One Arrives Ready
It sounds like preneed is already a priority for you, which is a great early step. A proactive program can relieve the burden of logistics on a grieving family after a loss and builds future—and current—value in your business.
You’re likely experiencing what so many others in the funeral profession are right now: increased costs of doing business paired with decreasing average funeral values, resulting in thin margins getting thinner.
It’s also true that people simply don’t want to talk about loss. Death and dying are rarely discussed in our society, so that conversation is one of the biggest obstacles in the funeral profession, even with families who’ve said they’re interested in preplanning.
To get them there, it takes thoughtful messaging, sensitive follow-ups, and an expert guide who knows how to walk them through a conversation they may not have felt comfortable having with their own family.
Surprisingly enough, your AFPs are no different. They don't arrive fully formed and ready to navigate the emotionally sensitive waters of a preplanning conversation — they're guided there, too. And that’s where a talented coach comes in.
Rhythm Over Rescue
Coaching is easy to treat as a remedy for someone who is struggling. But the strongest preneed programs treat it as scaffolding that’s always there to support consistent performance.
That scaffolding can be simple: a weekly one-on-one with your Advance Funeral Planner or a monthly ride-along. What matters is building a rhythm to ensure the conversation never stops.
One first step is to have your top-selling AFP walk you or your team through one real appointment a month. Discuss what they said, where the family hesitated, and what turned the appointment around.
This intentional focus allows skills to strengthen and grow. A skill discussed once fades; a skill revisited every week becomes instinct. And instinct is what helps your AFP spend more time focusing on the nuances of the conversation: emotional beats, each family’s unique situation, and what it is they’re really looking for.
Coaching is also how you catch the off weeks. When a top producer struggles, you’re able to work with them to shake it off before a slump becomes a pattern. And when they do, you can push them to achieve more than before.
The Same River
The question now is: What are you coaching?
Your AFPs and the families they meet travel the same emotional terrain. But they experience it much differently.
Think of it like rafting down a river. A guide looks at the river from a completely different lens and internalizes parts of the river most people may not even be aware of. On the other hand, a passenger is fully immersed in the moment. It’s new, it’s exciting, and they trust that they’ll arrive at their destination safely.
That same level of trust is what the most talented AFPs create, and they can be coached to expertly navigate the preneed experience every time. Every preneed appointment should be built deliberately around the "a-ha" moments that lead to exceptional experiences.
And when your AFP knows that design by heart, and the intention behind it, they can educate families about the value of a service that honors the people they love. The result is better experiences and more prearranged funerals.
You’re Not Alone
You mentioned a hands-on approach to preneed, and there's real value in that. But your days are already full — arrangements, staff, families, the business itself. So the question becomes: how sustainable is running your own program?
If you’re constantly required to check on and adjust pieces of your preneed program, that time comes from somewhere — usually from the parts of the business only you can do.
Some funeral homes designate a staff member whose sole role is coaching the preneed team. Many others find a trusted partner to handle preneed while they focus on running their core business.
Look for someone who has sat in living rooms themselves, and whose calendar can actually protect coaching time, not a staff member who inherits it as a ninth responsibility.
Whichever path you choose, a dedicated coach can turn the team you've already built into the program you've been hoping for.
Your Coaching Tree
Picture your funeral home two years from now.
The AFP you coach this fall is coaching someone new, passing down what they learned in living rooms and kitchen tables across your community. That's a coaching tree. And like the great ones, it's measured not by one person's wins but by the guides it produces.
You're in the arrangement room, at the community event, planning what your firm becomes next — while a team of guides serves more families than you ever could alone. Preneed stops being one more thing you manage and becomes the engine that drives everything else you want to do.
When every AFP knows the path by heart, more people in your community sit down for a conversation they've avoided and walk out with a plan that honors someone they love.
That's what coaching builds: results and the people who keep producing them. The talent was never untapped. It was waiting for a guide.
The moment your AFPs have one and your team has a rhythm and structure to hold them, consistency stops being something you chase. It becomes something your program produces.