Preneed Pro Tips: Build a Business That Lasts

I've spent 25 years building my funeral home into something I'm proud of. We have a great staff, steady call volume, and a good reputation in our community. I admit my preneed program is nothing to write home about, but that didn’t seem to matter until I started having real conversations about what comes next. How do I make sure my program is succession-ready? — Thinking Ahead 

Dear Thinking Ahead: That’s a great question, and I know a lot of funeral home owners out there who share your concerns. Managing a high-performing preneed program on top of running a successful funeral home is genuinely a lot to carry. 

At the same time, preneed is an increasingly important balance sheet item. It signals that you’re proactively building relationships in your community and gaining a steady stream of families who have fully committed to your brand. 

To help answer your question, let’s walk through how preneed factors into today’s valuation conversations. Then we’ll dive into why a thriving, well-built program can be a reliable second engine for your business, one that propels your work forward and honors the legacy you’ve been so devoted to building.  

Today’s Valuation Framework

When funeral home leaders start thinking about succession, valuation comes up fast. 

And while valuation may look like a snapshot of your business today, people are really wondering about tomorrow: How confident can I be that this business will keep performing? 

A sustained high volume of preneed answers that question before it’s even asked. It’s a known quantity: years of future revenue already in the pipeline, independent of next year’s call volume or market conditions. 

That predictability also helps your successors feel comfortable with next steps. When you are a new business owner, there is so much to manage. If you can take preneed off the plate, it’s one less unknown that successors will lose sleep over. 

A preneed program that reaches the right people at the right time, sets more appointments, and preplans more families without added oversight represents tangible growth for any leader who comes next.

Average funeral value matters here, too. A high-performing preneed program isn’t about selling preneed just to sell more preneed. It’s about educating families so they understand the value and meaning of a prearranged funeral.  

That record of trusted guidance is just as important to hand off as the keys to the front door. 

Preneed on the Balance Sheet

You’ve probably already seen how today’s consumer preferences are changing around funeral service. 

Without education or guidance, many consumers default to what they perceive as easier or less expensive. This leads to a downward compression on average funeral values, but a high-performing preneed program built on quality consumer experiences can change that. 

Consider what happens when call volume stays flat but average funeral values keep sliding. For a 350-call firm currently averaging $6,000 funerals, even a $100 year-over-year decline adds up fast. 

But the reverse is true as well. A proactive preneed program built on educating families and helping them see the value of ritual, ceremony, and gathering can significantly increase your overall volume and result in sustained higher average funeral values. 

With a high replacement ratio—prearrangements as a percentage of at-need calls—you’re investing in your present and your future. Proactive preneed can counter the declining margins many funeral home owners are seeing today.

Growing preneed also signals something that runs even deeper: community trust. Edelman’s 2025 Brand Trust report says trust is now as much a consideration for purchases as quality and price. 

Families don't prearrange with funeral homes they don't believe in. A deep backlog of preneed volume is evidence of a brand that has earned its place in the community. 

And while the best time to build a successful preneed program was likely years ago, the second-best time is right now. Doing so may be one of the strongest contributors to your business' future value. 

How Proactive Preneed Raises the Bar 

When a family sits down with an Advance Funeral Planner, the conversation can go places an at-need arrangement often can't. 

Families are more open to talking about loss and learning about the true impact it can have on their loved ones. They have space to understand why a funeral can give those left behind a place to heal when they are not experiencing the deep, acute grief that follows the death of a loved one.

Done well, a preneed experience grounded in education shifts the frame from price to meaning. Many families arrive thinking funerals come down to a choice between burial and cremation, but they leave knowing that a thoughtfully planned funeral is actually a gift for the loved ones they leave behind. 

That moment is pivotal, but the quality of the relationship you build through a high-performing program starts much earlier. It’s the preneed ad that attracts a family with a message that really resonates. It’s the caring, patient follow-ups that span weeks or even months until families are ready to take the next step and set an appointment. 

For a successor evaluating your funeral home, the quality of the preneed experience matters. The combination of high preneed volume and high average funeral values signals that families are being genuinely guided, and that they’re deeply loyal to your brand. 

5 Ways to Get Started 

It sounds like you’re serious about improving your program, Thinking Ahead. The great news is that there are really just five key areas to focus on. It can take time and a lot of work, and many funeral homes choose to outsource that work to a trusted partner. Either way, the result will help add value to your business today and support an intentional succession plan into the future.

1. Build a lead gen performance engine

A sustainable preneed program requires a mix of effective and consistent lead sources. These can range from community education programs to digital marketing and lead nurturing. The goal should be to reach the right people with the right message at the right times, which can be achieved through data analysis and testing. You can track what works by how many appointments result from your marketing. 

2. Develop a system for quality follow-ups 

Most families don’t schedule an appointment after the first follow-up. It takes a patient, caring approach, one that requires equal parts persistence and sensitivity. My best recommendation is to make sure you have someone solely dedicated to follow-ups. Then, focus on improving the quality of your appointment setting by measuring those appointments that do not get canceled and result in prearranged funerals. 

3. Invest in the quality of the appointment experience.

Done well, a quality preneed experience shifts the frame from cost to meaning. It’s where families who feel genuinely guided are far more likely to plan a service that truly reflects their loved one’s life. My best recommendation is to begin creating a framework so these kinds of experiences are repeatable. Between that and regular coaching, you will start seeing the benefits of more committed families and higher-quality plans.

4. Track all the right data 

You may have heard the saying “what gets measured gets managed.” In preneed, that means full-funnel metrics from first lead to prearranged funeral. Reliable preneed data allows you to make investments that have predictable outcomes, and it’s the surest path to continuous improvement. For a successor evaluating your business, this kind of operational visibility is invaluable. 

5. Build a preneed team that lasts 

This is the one that ties everything together. In his book “Good to Great,” Jim Collins famously said you have to get the right people on the bus—and then get them in the right seats. A solid preneed team is similar. More than just a single salesperson, it takes appointment-setting specialists, data analysts, performance marketers, and logistics experts all working together to make an impact.  A team built that way doesn’t depend on any one leader to sustain it, and it gives a successor every reason to believe the best is still ahead. 

Previous
Previous

Preneed Pro Tips: Turning Talent Into Results

Next
Next

Show Up Where It Counts